Gainesville (352) 448-9095 Tampa (813) 922-1528

The Smartest Move You’ll Ever Make™

Get A Free Moving Quote
  • All Fields Are Required

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • Hidden
  • By providing a telephone number you are opting in to receiving text messages.

What’s Living in Lake Butler Like? | What to Know Before Moving to Lake Butler FL

What’s Living in Lake Butler Like? 🛶 | What to Know Before Moving to Lake Butler FL

Last Updated on: 12th August 2023, 05:00 pm

Not to be confused with Lake Butler, a city in Union County, FL, today we’re referring to Lake Butler in Orange County, or Lake Butler, Windermere, which is an Orlando suburb. If you’re considering moving to Lake Butler, we’ve written a comprehensive guide on what to expect; we’re covering topics from population to crime rate and even top restaurants!

Lake Butler is an unincorporated Orange County census-designated place or CDP. The CDP is built around and named after the area’s renowned body of water, Lake Butler, which is one of 13 lakes in Florida’s “Butler Chain of Lakes.” It’s 1611 acres and is commonly used for recreational purposes such as boating and fishing. The lake’s water quality has an exceptional reputation and offers an optimal habitat for the area’s wildlife. Living in Lake Butler is very good regardless, but especially If you enjoy the relaxed-vibe lake-side living embodies and prefer proximity to a larger city.

Where Is Lake Butler?

The CDP of Lake Butler is located in Orange County, FL, and is situated southwest of Orlando. It contains Windermere, Isleworth, Summerport Beach and Is boarded by Horizon West and Bay Hill. This attractive suburb is only 17 miles from Orlando and is part of the  Orlando–Kissimmee–Sanford, Florida Metropolitan Statistical Area.

While mostly developed into newer-construction homes and commercial buildings, select areas of the CDP boast picturesque Florida views!

Lake Butler Population & Demographics

The population of Lake Butler is 18,851, which is 3,451 more than in 2010. There are 5,420 households in Lake Butler, Florida; 36% of residents moved into their homes between 2015 and 2016, and only 4% of residents have lived there since the 90s. 70% of the population is married, 30% is single, and 48% of the population is under the age of 40. It boasts the highest median household income in the county—$132,958.

Additional Lake Butler, FL demographics:

  • Median age: 41.7 years old
  • Sex ratio: 50 males to 50 females
  • Racial and ethnic composition: 62.7% White (57.2% non-Hispanic), 16.5% Asian, 13.1% Hispanic or Latino, 10% two or more, 8% Black or African American
  • Educational attainment: 59.9% have bachelor’s degrees or higher (Florida: 31.5%)
  • Foreign-born population: 22.8% (Florida 11%)
  • Veteran population: 4.1% (Florida 8.2%)

People living in Lake Butler are educated and have diverse ethnic backgrounds.

Is Lake Butler safe?

The crime rate in Lake Butler is 878 per 100k people, compared to Florida’s 2,153 per 100k people and the nation’s crime rate of 2,346 per 100k people.

  • Lake Butler violent crime rate per 100k people: 157
  • Florida violent crime rate per 100k people: 384
  • US violent crime rate per 100k people: 388
  • Lake Butler property crime rate per 100k people: 722
  • Florida property crime rate per 100k people: 1769
  • US property crime rate per 100k people: 1,958

The Orange County Police Department protects the citizens of Lake Butler; Lake Butler has a lower crime rate than the state and nation, making it a very safe place to live! However, even though it’s considered quiet and safe, it’s always smart to browse a Lake Butler crime map when house shopping!

Things to Do in Lake Butler

Living in Lake Butler provides countless amenities; there are even noteworthy shopping centers; Shoppes at Lake Butler and Winter Garden Village are two of the best shopping options in and near Lake Butler.

R.D. Keene Park

One of the most popular parks in the CDP is R.D. Keene. It’s located near Lake Louise. There is a paved loop that is ideal for walking, skating, or bike riding. 

10900 Chase Rd, Windermere, FL 34786, (407) 254-1940

Isleworth Golf & Country Club

Isleworth Golf and Country Club is in the community of Isleworth, which is located within Lake Butler. If you’re moving to Lake Butler to pursue your golf hobby, you’ll want proximity to top golfing facilities! Isleworth boasts a collection of amenities ranging from beautiful homes, a resort-style pool and a pristine 18-hole course. 

5480 Isleworth Country Club Dr, Windermere, FL 34786, (407) 909-2000

Additional attractions near Lake Butler

Lake Butler Restaurants

There are numerous tasty eateries in and near Lake Butler; here are the top Lake Butler restaurants!

Tomatoes Home Style Cooking

Tomatoes Home Style Cooking is a well-renowned Greek-fusion restaurant a few miles outside of Lake Butler. The menu includes unique dishes such as kabobs, gyros, and stuffed grape leaves. If you’d like to experience home-style cooking from across the world, Tomatoes is the place to try!

Tomatoes Home Style Cooking 4848 S Apopka Vineland Rd Suite 208, Orlando, FL 32819

Dixie Cream Cafe

located in the heart of Windermere (a town within Lake Butler) is Dixies Cream Cafe. Indulge in the delicious lunch and breakfast menu while enjoying the restaurant’s eclectic vibe and unique artwork.

Dixie Cream Cafe 434 Main St, Windermere, FL 34786

Average Rent & Homes for Sale in Lake Butler

With a Lake Butler median sale price of 1.4 million, the housing market is considered somewhat competitive—-the median sale price is up 59.1% since 2022. Homes typically sell within 27 days, and 42 homes sold in June, which is quite impressive considering the CDP’s size. The median price per square foot is $347, 18% higher than in 2022. Considering homes are going fast, consider browsing homes for sale in Lake Butler, FL.

There are 5,520 households in Lake Butler, with an average of 3.2 people per household. 86% are owner-occupied (compared to the nation’s 66%), and 14% are renter-occupied. 88% are single-unit structures (or single-family homes), and 11% are multi-unit structures.

Lake Butler, FL, is a suburban CDP where most people are homeowners, there are no apartment complexes within the CDP limits, but there are many in neighboring cities like Winter Garden and Orlando. Any rentals in Lake Butler are single-family homes. Most apartments outside of the city are brand-new construction; however, there are some rundown areas to steer clear of. The average rent in Lake Butler is 2,370 for a 1,115-square-foot rental.

Jobs in Lake Butler

Despite being small, Lake Butler has seen a 3.9% job market increase since 2022 and is projected to see a 50.1% increase by 2033, which is much higher than the US average of 33.5%.

The main industries in the area are accommodation and food services, arts and entertainment, health care and social assistance, and retail trade. Most people commute to nearby cities like Orlando and Winter Garden for higher-paying, more competitive job opportunities. 75.4% of commuters drive alone, 8.04% carpool, and 10.4% work from home—the average commute time is 26.9 minutes.

The average hourly wage in Lake Butler is $14.58, and the average salary is $50,000. 26.3% of Lake Butler residents earn more than $200,000 annually, and only 2% make between $15,000 and $20,000. The major employers in and near Lake Butler are Walt Disney World Resort (7 miles away), Orlando Health (7.4 miles away), and Orlando International Airport (23.7 miles away).

We know job hunting can feel overwhelming, but there are many jobs in Lake Butler, FL, that are awaiting your application! County and city jobs are great options too. Since Lake Butler is an unincorporated community and Orange County handles the typical duties of a city government, Orange County jobs would be where you’d look.

Lake Butler Schools

Before moving to Lake Butler, it’s important to note there are no schools within the limits of the CDP; however, the wonderful Orange County Public School District serves the Lake Butler area. It contains 264 schools and a student-teacher ratio of 17:1; there is a large minority enrollment of 80%, and 35.4% are economically disadvantaged.

A few schools the residents of Lake Butler are zoned for are Chain of Lakes Middle School, Palm Lake Elementary School, Bay Lake Elementary, Windermere Elementary (rated 10/10 by Great Schools), Keenes Crossing Elementary, and Sunset Park Elementary.

Suppose you or a loved one is interested in advancing their education. In that case, there are numerous nearby colleges to choose from – Valencia College and the University of Central Florida. If you’re already in school and need a quiet place to study or are searching for a kid-friendly activity, the Windermere Branch Library is a great option.

Lake Butler Statistic and Information

  • County: Orange County
  • Lake Butler area: 20.4 square miles
  • Lake Butler zip code: 34786
  • Lake Butler area code: 386
  • Elevation: 106 ft
  • Time zone: Eastern Daylight Time
  • The closest airport to Lake Butler: Orlando International Airport (MCO) is 23.7 miles from Lake Butler

Map of Lake Butler

Explore more things to do in and near this terrific CDP with this map of Lake Butler!

If you’re considering moving to Lake Butler, we’re sure you’re ready to experience everything this Orlando suburb offers! While relocating is very exciting, it may pose challenges without professional help; instead of starting your journey on a stressful foot, let 2 College Brothers provide skilled Lake Butler movers; we can make this transition feel simple and stress-free; call us at 813-922-1529 for a free estimate.


"*" indicates required fields

All Fields Are Required

MM slash DD slash YYYY

Search by Category

Search For more helpful Resources

Check Out Our Related posts